I'm new to this forum. In fact I just discovered the Rohrbaugh today.
Some thoughts. I've owned a S&W 340 PD with an OA sights big dot sight for a couple of years.
Recoil: It is quite a handful when full of .357 mag, but it is not uncontrolable. Every time I go shooting, I make it a point to put 5 rounds through the little gun. It beats me up, but by forcing myself to consistently fire a small number of rounds through it, I am maintaining proficiency. I'm also now pretty used to the recoil. While I can't exactly double tap, my follow up shots can be pretty quick now.
Is it a pocket gun? Absolutely it is. I have a Kahr PM9, previously the smallest and lightest 9mm. I've found that the weight of the Kahr makes it impractical for pocket carry. In contrast the Jframe is so light that it can go in the front pocket of my jeans easily. Also, while it is thicker than a semi auto, the lumpy shape of the revolver breaks up its silhouette. Someone said that for it to be a pocket pistol it had to fit in the back pocket. That seems strange, I dont' know anyone who carries a gun in their back pocket.
With thiat said, I'm really interested in theis new Rohrbaugh. It will not replace my Kahr. I can shoot an IDPA qualifier with the little Kahr and do reasonably well (almost can shoot expert level with it). I think the Rohrbaugh is going to be too much of a handful for that.
Finally, my way of dress is such that before all these great little powerhouses came out, I stuck with my Seecamp. I typically wear jeans, khakis, shorts with a dress shirt or polo shirt. I don't wear vests or suits. So I have little opportunity to carry conceiled durring work unless it goes in my pocket. These are great times. The R9 looks like another great tool to keep on hand.
Don