I have no experience with the ones you mentioned, but I did find a good short term solution if you don't mind IWB carry. I picked up a Bianchi clip-on IWB, right hand, model 6D-9A and it fits the R9s beautifully. I think I paid about $25. It has an adjustable thumb break strap which retains the gun well. If you're looking for a cheap & easy solution while you shop for your ideal holster, this might work well. Hope this helps.